C.A.M.P. Carbon Fiber Avalanche Probe: Featherweight

Packed size: 40 centimeters

Weight: 123 grams (4.34 ounces)

Price: $69.95

I typically relate to the mountain maxim "light is right" when it comes to hefting gear. I was excited to learn, then, that C.A.M.P. had released a carbon fiber avalanche probe that weighs just over 4 ounces. Though marketed for "competitive ski mountaineering," and complying with the minimum requirements of the International Ski Mountaineering Federation, I have a feeling that its featherweight design will attract more than lycra-clad rando racers. Who wouldn't want to shave a few more ounces from their packs? When I received the probe, however, it seemed to lack heft and lateral stiffness, and so, before even bringing it into the field, I was concerned with how well it would perform.

With numerous backcountry ski tours under my belt throughout this past ski season, I was able to test the probe in a wide variety of snow conditions, from deep winter snowpacks to wet slide debris. My initial concerns were mostly put to rest until the densest of debris paths served up a challenge for the probe's lateral stability. Although it sank remarkably smoothly in most types of snow, the chances of breaking the probe's thin carbon fiber segments became all too realistic when I felt it bend its way in and out of icy, hardened chunks of compact snow. Under the same circumstances, a standard probe would certainly have performed better, but for now the unit remained intact, exceeding my expectations for such a lightweight probe.

I thought it reliable enough to take it on a ski trip to Montana's Spanish Peaks. Questioning the stability of the north-facing slope we were about to enter, we decided to dig a snowpit. I pulled the probe out of its bag, and while assembling it, I noticed that the plastic piece—fixed at the end of the cord to keep the probe together—had somehow fallen off. I disappointingly watched as each segment freely slid down and off the 2mm Dyneema cord, soundlessly landing on the white surface. Putting the probe together has proven nothing short of annoying since then.

I still believe in shaving off a few ounces here and there whenever possible, but only so long as my safety or the reliability of the gear is not compromised. C.A.M.P.'s Carbon Fiber Avalanche Probe is well suited for randonnee racers and weight-conscious backcountry skiers who will not encounter heavy and thick avalanche debris. The durability caveat I experienced could have been specific to just this one piece, but it has nevertheless decreased my enthusiasm in recommending this probe as a reliable alternative to heftier models for everyday backcountry use.

Pros: Lightweight; fairly stiff and effective in all but the thickest avalanche debris.

Cons: Fragile parts can threaten the structural integrity of the assembly system.

Rating:

skeptic

Quote: "When I received the probe, however, it seemed to lack heft and lateral stiffness, and so, before even bringing it into the field, I was concerned with how well it would perform."

Quote: "the chances of breaking the probe's thin carbon fiber segments became all too realistic when I felt it bend its way in and out of icy, hardened chunks of compact snow. Under the same circumstances, a standard probe would certainly have performed better"

Quote: "while assembling it, I noticed that the plastic piece—fixed at the end of the cord to keep the probe together—had somehow fallen off. I disappointingly watched as each segment freely slid down and off the 2mm Dyneema cord"

A three star rating is reserved for 'above average' product performance. Unlike a rock shoe or a soft shell jacket, an Avy probe is most useful when the situation has become most desparate. It is a tool designed to save a life. This appears to be an excellent review but I don't understand the three star rating.

2008-07-28 21:48:27

Login with your username and password below.
New User? Here's what to do.

Username

Password

Forgot your username or password?